First Choice Insurance Agency is dedicated to complete customer satisfaction. For over 30 years, agency owner and President, Michael J. Perna has assisted thousands of individuals throughout Illinois secure the proper insurance coverage to fit their needs. We provide service on Major Medical Plans, Group Insurance, Life Insurance, Annuities, Long Term Care, HSA’s, Home Health Care and Medicare Supplements. We are a fully licensed insurance agency in several states. All of our brokers and employees strive to protect the assets and values of each individual policy holder at the highest level of excellence. 

We realize the quest for insurance can be an exasperating one. With so many insurance options out there, it’s difficult to know which way to turn. At First Choice Insurance Agency we pride ourselves on 100% customer satisfaction, and we uphold this by working for you, the customer and your best interest -- not the insurance companies. We’re able to provide a wide array of insurance products to fit each client’s individual needs. A plan that works for your neighbor may not necessarily be the best plan for you. We have a specially trained staff, willing to listen to your goals, find the coverage that is right for you, as well as educate you about all of the options available. We provide a no cost or obligation personal interview to design a plan of action tailored specifically to fit your needs.

First Choice Insurance Agency represents leading insurance carriers that specialize in programs designed to protect individuals and their personal finances. Our team of Brokers are trained to be on the cutting edge of new products and programs available to you. We have an energetic staff on call to answer any questions you may have, eliminating the frustration of being bounced around through automated systems and switchboards.

Every day thousands of individuals experience serious and often unexpected illnesses and injuries that can deplete not only ones’ quality of life, but also their valuable assets or life savings. Whether you’re looking to protect your family or increase your personal finances, we can help. 

We are a proud member of the Better Business Bureau with an A+ rating and the National Ethics Association.

First Choice Insurance Agency BBB Business Review